Climate risk, insurance, and the future of fisheries and aquaculture
QUESTION
How can the insurance sector adapt its products and risk assessment frameworks to account for the increasing frequency and severity of climate-driven events (e.g., marine heatwaves, storms, disease outbreaks), and what innovative insurance models could support the long-term resilience of fishers and aquaculture producers?
ANSWER 1
By: Dr Alistair HobdayFinancial instruments such as insurance are available to help farmers manage climate shocks such as drought. Yet, similar risk management tools are almost entirely absent from coastal communities. Ensuring resilience and adaptability of the seafood sector in the face of accelerating climate change involves risk management and risk reduction. In a world where climate patterns are rapidly evolving, innovative financial instruments have a role to play in managing environmental risks and reducing exposure to these risks through climate adaptation. There is a current working group (Australia and USA) https://oceanmodelingforum.org/working-groups/risk-management-in-fisheries/ considering options and working with industries and insurance brokers.
Parametric insurance—when a predetermined amount is paid out based on parameters chosen based on expected losses associated with extreme events – is seen as one approach that can confer some resilience on industries that may lose catch as a result of extreme events.
It is a very topical issue – you can read more in these papers.
- Hobday, A. J., L. R. Little, J. R. Watson and C. M. Spillman (2025). “Parametric Insurance for Climate Adaptation in Fisheries and Aquaculture.” Reviews in Fish Biology and Fisheries: https://doi.org/10.1007/s11160-11025-09920-11163.
- Watson, J. R., C. M. Spillman, L. R. Little, A. J. Hobday and P. S. Levin (2023). “Ensuring resilience to marine climate shocks through insurance.” ICES Journal of Marine Science 10: 2457–2469 https://doi.org/2410.1093/icesjms/fsad2175.
Answered by:
Dr Alistair Hobday
ANSWER 2
By: Mr Matt WeaverHow can the insurance sector adapt its products and risk assessment frameworks, and what innovative models could support long-term resilience?
The premise is worth challenging: the products already exist. The common assumption is that climate change has outrun the insurance market and that new products must be invented before fishers and aquaculture producers can be protected. In practice the aquaculture insurance market is more capable today than at any point in the last fifteen years.
- Capacity is at a fifteen year high, with four global insurers actively writing aquaculture risk and openly seeking new business.
- Alongside the traditional indemnity carriers, a parallel panel of parametric insurers now underwrites marine and climate indices for this sector.
- Climate risk is already an explicit underwriting consideration, assessed at both site-specific and global level, with focus on the exact drivers that matter here: high water temperature, plankton blooms, disease and storm activity.
The real constraint is not product availability. It is that too few producers are presented with a solution designed around their own operation, their own perils and their own balance sheet. The gap is in structuring and advice, not in invention.
Two forms of insurance coverage, and how they can work together
Indemnity insurance responds to mortality or physical loss of insured stock arising from a sudden and unforeseen event, either on an all-risks basis or against a named peril list that varies for onshore and offshore sites. The named perils already extend to storm, natural catastrophe, plankton bloom, deoxygenation, high water temperature, adverse water chemistry and disease. It remains the backbone of any programme.
Its limits are structural rather than a failure of the market. Cover is event-driven and requires a provable incident, consequential loss is excluded, and losses that are unexplained or only identified at grading, sampling or harvest fall outside the policy. A prolonged marine heatwave that suppresses growth, feed conversion and condition without a single identifiable mortality event sits awkwardly against that definition.
Parametric insurance pays automatically when a pre-agreed, independently verifiable index crosses a defined threshold. Triggers relevant to this sector include wind speed or named storm, wave height, water temperature, chlorophyll-a concentration and salinity. Claims settle in days or weeks rather than months.
Parametric is not a replacement technology or a competitor to indemnity. It is a second tool, and it can be deployed in four distinct ways:
- Complement. Sit alongside an existing indemnity programme, targeting the perils that drive the most volatility.
- Enhance. Buy down a deductible that has risen to the point where the working layer is effectively self-insured, or top up a limit that no longer reflects stock values.
- Replace. Where a producer concludes that the indemnity market does not understand their operation, or where terms, exclusions and claims experience have eroded confidence, a parametric structure can carry the programme on its own.
- Extend. Cover exposures the indemnity market does not reach at all: consequential and revenue loss, emergency harvest and relocation costs, lost growing season, and slow-onset temperature stress that never produces a discrete insurable event.
One caveat applies across all four. Parametric only works where the selected index correlates tightly with the financial loss. Where it does not, saying so protects both the producer and the credibility of the product, and sometimes the right answer is mitigation or retention rather than transfer.
The industry solution: formalised self-insurance
The single largest opportunity for this sector is not a new product from an insurer. It is for the industry to take deliberate ownership of the risk it is already carrying informally, and to fund it through a structured vehicle.
Every producer self-insures today, whether they intend to or not. Deductibles have risen, exclusions bite, and the working layer of loss is absorbed through cashflow and balance sheet. What is missing is the discipline of pricing that retained layer, funding it before the event rather than after, and using the resulting pool to negotiate properly with the commercial market.
Three vehicles are relevant, in increasing order of structure and capital commitment:
- Discretionary trust. A trust holding member contributions, paying claims at the discretion of trustees against agreed protocols. It is the lowest barrier to entry, avoids the capital and prudential burden of a licensed insurer, and can cover exposures the commercial market excludes or prices punitively. It suits an industry association structure well and is proven across Australian agriculture, local government and the not-for-profit sector.
- Industry mutual. A member-owned insurer where the producers are also the owners. Surplus is retained in the pool rather than ceded to shareholders, underwriting standards are set by people who understand the operations, and good risk management is rewarded directly through contribution rates.
- Captive or protected cell. For larger single operators or a group of them, a captive formalises the retention, gives direct access to reinsurance rather than retail terms, and creates a vehicle into which parametric recoveries can be received and allocated.
Why this matters:
- It solves the understanding problem. The most common complaint from producers is that the commercial market does not understand their operation. A mutual is underwritten by people who do.
- It funds the uninsured middle. Attritional losses, consequential and business interruption exposure, emergency harvest and relocation costs, and the slow-onset temperature stress that no indemnity policy responds to. These are precisely the exposures a discretionary fund can be written to cover.
- It gives scale to small operators. Individual small fishers and small producers cannot economically access bespoke structuring. A pool can. It spreads the fixed cost of design and analytics across members and carries enough aggregate premium to attract reinsurance and parametric capacity on sensible terms.
- It is often the only route for wild-catch fishers. Wild-catch operators have no stock to indemnify and no insurable asset beyond the vessel, so the traditional market has little to offer them against climate risk. Their exposure is lost fishing days from wind and wave conditions, cyclone-driven port closures, and fishery closures triggered by harmful algal blooms or temperature-driven stock movement. All of these are parametrically measurable, but no individual operator carries the premium volume to structure cover alone. A pooled vehicle makes it viable.
- It creates the data asset. A pool collects loss and event data on a consistent basis from day one. Within a few years that is the single most valuable thing the industry can hold, because insurers price uncertainty and this sector’s terms are shaped by thin data rather than by bad risk.
- It changes the negotiation. A pool buys reinsurance rather than retail insurance. It can place a parametric layer above its own retention, take back the margin currently paid away on frequency losses, and approach the commercial market as a counterparty rather than a supplicant.
- It rewards resilience. Contribution rates set by the pool can give immediate and transparent credit for backup generation, oxygenation, sensor networks, submersible pens, vaccination programmes and site selection, in a way the commercial market has been slower to do.
This is also where public funding does the most good. Rather than ad hoc post-event relief, a seeding contribution to a mutual’s capital base, or support for the reinsurance or parametric layer above it, builds a permanent capability and crowds in private capital. The same architecture underpins sovereign disaster risk financing across the Pacific.
Where the sector genuinely does need to sharpen
If the question is what should change, I would point to execution rather than product design.
- Underwrite the forward risk, not the back-cast. Where hazard is non-stationary, a five or ten year loss record understates forward exposure and penalises operators who were simply unlucky in a short window. Satellite sea surface temperature records, chlorophyll-a climatology, wave and wind hindcasts and downscaled projections are all available and free, and allow a lease-level view rather than a class-level one.
- Price the site, not the sector. Two leases twenty kilometres apart can differ materially in flushing, depth, stratification and bloom exposure. A single aquaculture rate misprices in both directions and ultimately pushes capacity away from good sites as well as bad.
- Give structured credit for mitigation. The industry is already investing in a wide range of mitigation strategies. If those investments are not recognised in rate, deductible or terms, the business case for funding them weakens, and insurability declines for everyone.
Supporting long-term resilience
- Quantify in dollars. The most useful output for a producer board is the distribution of revenue outcomes today, in five years and in thirty, and how much of the downside tail can be transferred. That converts an abstract climate discussion into a capital allocation decision, and it aligns with what the Australian Sustainability Reporting Standards now require of larger reporters.
- Use insurance to lower the cost of capital. Lenders and investors are increasingly pricing physical climate risk into the cost of capital for coastal and marine assets, and a credible multi-year risk transfer programme is often what makes a project financeable at all. We have seen banks in the agriculture sector offer improved lending terms once they understand the mechanics of a parametric structure, because cover that responds automatically to climate and other measurable events reduces the borrower’s volatility and therefore the lender’s credit risk. On that view premium stops being a cost line and starts being an investment in the terms on which capital is available.
In short:
The aquaculture insurance market has already begun adapting. Capacity is strong, climate risk is already in the underwriting, and between indemnity and parametric there are very few exposures that cannot be structured for. The work that remains is twofold. At the individual level, sit with each producer, understand their operation and their cashflow, and build the right combination of the two tools that already exist. At the industry level, formalise the self-insurance that is already happening by accident into a trust or mutual that prices the retained layer, holds the data and buys the rest properly.
Answered by: